The Nuclear Juggernaut


Part  3
The nuclear juggernaut after 1945

Juggernaut


1950s

The Consolidated Vultee B-36 'Peacemaker'

Consolidated Vultee B-36 Peacemaker

Originating from a design competition AFTER the Battle of Britain and BEFORE Pearl Harbor ... this long range bomber was designed for intercontinental missions, finally entering service with the US Strategic Air Command in June 1948. The air-cooled pusher propeller engines were rated at 3000-3800 hp each and later models of the bomber included the turbojet engines shown.

It was best suited for bombing Europe from a distance (e.g. from a base in Gander, Newfoundland) ... if Britain and its air bases had been knocked out of World War 2 by Germany. The bomber saw only slightly more than a decade of Cold War service before it became obsolete. In 1948, it was the only aircraft which could carry the comparatively unwieldy nuclear weapons of the time to the Soviet Union ... with a total bomb-load of 23 tons.

One was also modified to carry a small working atomic reactor ... to assess whether military aircraft could be powered by atoms to increase their range and endurance.


Chart: total nuclear bombs, total bomber aircraftThe Nuclear Juggernaut
from 'Moral Principles and Nuclear Weapons' Douglas P. Lackey, 1984


Thanks to Air Force lobbying and tradition, 'manned intercontinental bombers'
... as were used to fight the last world war ...
were initially the 'weapons of choice' for the United States.

In the US there was a well-established industry and they made good aircraft, such as the B-52
...
many of which, with extensive modifications, were still flying 50 years later ...


Boeing B-52 Stratofortress
If you had one of these Stratofortresses ... what could possibly scare you?


Four years after Stalin's death ...
and a year after Stalin was denunciated by Khrushchev ...

 ... in 1957 ...

Those paradigm-shifting Soviets ... with little domestic heavy aircraft industry profits to feed ...
opted for something more stylish and futuristic to demonstrate their atomic manliness.


Sputnik 1 'Fellow Traveller'
Very scary ... Sputnik 1 ... it beeps!

The first artificial object in earth orbit ...
Sputnik ('Fellow Traveller') 1 ... got there by riding the world's first intercontinental ballistic missile.


With its sinister communist beeping it 'mooned' the USA about every 90 minutes.



Overheard in the Eisenhower White House the night Sputnik was launched ...


"Hello, Pentagon? ... White House here.
... how could we NOT know! ... all three TV networks are playing the beep!
... say, might you have someone there who knows about 'rockets' ?
... Oh, yeah ... him.
... still smokes his cigarettes funny, fork in the wrong hand ? Figured. His old salute is gone I hope.
... you're sure he's not related to Hitler's girlfriend, though? ... good enough ...
OK, thanks buddy ... I'll give Disney a call next and see maybe if we can 'Walt-wash' him again for the voters."






Citizens! ... Consumers! ...

We've been through the Great Depression ...
We've been through the most terrible war the world has seen ...

Now, let's finally enjoy the good things of life !


Let's show them what they've won!

The explosion of consumer goods helped fuel the post-war manufacturing economies of America and Canada.
These appliances all run on electricity ... and where's that going to come from? ...

*  *  *

The Powered Future

(1954, US)

"No longer will India have to remain starved for the horsepower that is needed to run factories. Her 400 million people will have a chance to work, to raise themselves from depths of hopeless poverty.

"Australia can have all the power she wants - enough to irrigate the Great Victoria desert. Water, too, can be brought to the fertile soils of the Sahara, to the dry plains of Southwest Africa.

"Arctic snows can be melted. Antarctica's rich mineral deposits can be exploited. New industrial centers can be built in the wilds of North Canada.

"Holland with no power resources except imported fuels sees uranium as the cheapest answer yet to future needs.

"Britain figures atomic power is her best hope. In fewer than 30 years coal output will not meet her power needs. She plans within 25 years to fill more than half her requirements with nuclear reactors.

"Brazil thinks atomic power may be the least costly - and the quickest - way for her to unlock her inland jungles.

"Atomic power plants may never be made so compact as to fit under the hood of the family car, but 25-50 years from now - when world oil reserves may have dwindled sharply, when gasoline supplies have tightened - the atom may supply the energy needed to convert coal into liquid fuels.

"By then the diesel locomotive will be obsolete, a curio like the steam engine. By then atomic engines will haul the nation's trains, each unit putting out many times the diesel's 1500 horsepower.

"By then, too, the world's navies, merchant fleets will run on uranium, instead of coal and oil.

"The atom's place in the sky still is not clear. It may power bombers, long range missiles or a few extra-large round-the-world airliners. Too, it may provide man with the vast thrust he needs to break loose from the earth's gravitational pull - to being his inevitable 'conquest of the infinite'."


'Hello dispatcher, I've sent the trainee headend brakeman back to see about the leak."
(image from 'The Book of the Atom, 1960, British)





Cover: Atomic Bombing How to Protect Yourself
(1950, US)

"After a war must come peace. If we could break this chain in the future, the very real conflicts between communism and democracy might be resolved without the waste of devastating war. There would need to be realization on both sides that, short of unthinkable annihilation of all who differ with each other, the opponents must reconcile their conflicts.

"This is the catch in the situation: We can control atoms so much more effectively than men's minds and emotions, particularly human behavior behind the iron curtain.

"If we can try to control human behavior, through the United Nations, through as cool a war of ideas and words as possible, through mobilization of world opinion, as well as marshalling of our military strength, the falling of A-bombs may be prevented.

"If A-bombs fall, it will be another failure in our civilization - but most of us will live on even through such a disaster."



Poor old New York.



Poor old New York.


"WHAT AN A-BOMB WILL DO"

"Out of the sun a black, cigar-shaped object falls toward the earth. At the edge of town a filling station attendant sees it cross the slice of sky between the car above him and the edge of his grease pit. The center fielder of the visiting baseball team sees the moving spot, then looks back toward the batter, impatient for the third out. A woman in the park hears a strange, thin whistle and looks up, shading her eyes.

"At a point 2000 feet above the ground, the first atomic rocket of World War III explodes over your city. In one vast flash of light, equal to 100 suns, the buildings are etched against a sky of fire. A blinding ball of flame leaps from the point where the rocket exploded.

"There, in a millionth of a second, a lump of plutonium or uranium, perhaps the size of a basketball, disappears. As it vanishes, the temperature at that point jumps to 1,000,000 degrees Centigrade. The air around it is pushed outward by a pressure hundreds of thousands times that of the normal pressure of the atmosphere.

"A thousandth of a second later, the ball of fire is 45 feet across. Its temperature has dropped to 300,000 degrees.

"After a full second, there is a globe of flaming air 450 feet wide, the size of a city block.

"The shadows cast by this ball of fire are etched permanently into concrete sidewalks and granite buildings. Directly beneath the burst, in the split second before the blast wave arrives, pedestrians simply vanish into smoke and ash. This is the point which atomic scientists call "ground zero". Here the sidewalk temperature is between 3,000 and 4,000 degrees.

"With the sheer flash heat comes another form of radiating energy, the only one which a conventional high-explosives bomb cannot match on its smaller scale: Nuclear radiation, X-rays of the A-bomb, invisible yet striking through concrete and steel to destroy the single human cells in bone marrow, blood and living tissues.

"Then the blast hits. A moving wall of shock crushes the city under a giant hand, wrenches it from it foundations, levels a mile-wide area into rubble. Small masonry buildings are engulfed by a pressure wave and collapse completely. Light buildings and homes are totally demolished by the blast. Factories of steel are stripped of roofing and siding. Only twisted skeletons remain, leaning away from ground zero as though struck by a hurricane of stupendous proportions.

"When the shock and blinding heat have gone, fire springs up in the wreckage. And billowing out in great clouds of dust, falling back to earth from the towering mushroom of smoke, there is the hidden terror which scientists call residual radioactivity."


Protection is possible.
[Enjoying the new post-war quality of life, sir?]


"ATOMIC FORCES"

"When energy is released suddenly by any sort of bomb, the rise in temperature of the exploding materials causes complete vaporization of the bomb, casing and all. Solid matter suddenly turns to gas.

"This gas is in a restricted space, pushing outward with high pressure on the air around it. So great is this push that it can move air, water or earth, whatever is around the bomb when it goes off. The series of events which follow constitute the destructive blast of the bomb. In TNT and atomic bomb alike, blast does nearly all the physical damage by brute force. The tremendous heat generated by the explosion sends forth energy in a second way, which the scientists call thermal radiation. This is heat traveling with the speed of light, heat exactly like that given off by the sun. The rays are not penetrating. They are stopped by any object which stops light.

"Alone in the atomic bomb, rays of nuclear fission channel a third explosion of energy. When the radioactive material of the bomb disintegrates, it releases various particles of electricity: beta particles, the atom's electrons; alpha particles, which are combinations of neutrons and protons; neutrons alone, the particles from the center of atoms; and finally gamma rays, which are high-energy rays very similar to X-rays.

"The cumulative effect of these sources of energy is the measure of the atomic bomb, or of any other explosion of nuclear force, whether it be in the fission of uranium or the fusion of hydrogen in the 'Hell-bomb'."



This refrain may sound familiar to Canadian ears ...


... as Canada Geese hover above ...


*  *  *

"The leaders of organized religion in the United States are well aware of the tensions and uncertainties of the times. The threat to our national security is very real. Planning against possible disaster does not mean that war is inevitable, but not to plan against it would be negligent folly. The clergy and religions organizations of the country have a definite responsibility to participate actively in such planning and should have a comprehensive and organized role in civil defense in their communities.

"While the spiritual resources of organized religion must be considered in relation to the entire defense effort, the maintenance of the normal offices and practice of religion will promote security and spiritual composure for members of the different faiths in the present period of tension. Interrelationships and loyalties within religious groups provide stability and purpose for living in time of emotional stress and uncertainties.

"Worship, preaching, religious rites, and the activities of religious groups are especially helpful in preventing panic. In time of atomic or other attack upon the Nation, the demand upon the religious resources of the country would be unprecedented. The ministry of religious institutions and bodies would be vital in helping families and individuals to return to normal living following an enemy attack, thus strengthening the home front to carry on until victory is achieved." [emphasis mine]


from 'The Clergy in Civil Defense' (1951 US)



A novelty song which cleverly summarizes the development of atomic weapons
and the post-war dilemma faced by the citizens of the world is ...

'Old Man Atom'

... "Einstein says he's scared, and when Einstein's scared, I'm scared"


Several versions are available on iTunes.

The 1950 interpretation by the Sons of the Pioneers provides the most interesting mix of lyrics and arrangement.

This version of the 1946 song is fascinating as a 'historical artifact' for another reason.
It's composer was Vern Partlow, a reporter with the "Daily News" of Los Angeles.
The idea came to him after repeated assignments to interview atomic scientists after the war, who had come to LA to speak.

Those campaigning against communism around 1950 ...
at the time of the United Nations sponsored Korean War, and just after the Revolution in China ...
complained loudly that the 'new' song promoted a contemporary Communist 'peace' message.

RCA Victor self-censored by pulling the Sons of the Pioneers version in spite of the fact
that theirs, and other versions, were very popular at the time.

There were numerous editorial complaints in newspapers about the withdrawal of the song,
but it disappeared until revived by others in the 1960s.
Partlow was blacklisted.



The late 1950s & early 1960s in 'MAD Magazine'

DuPont U-235



... after an old Dean Martin song.


Wernher von Braun and other Nazi Wehrmacht military rocket scientists and technicians ...
and as much technology as could be carted out of Europe before the Soviets arrived ...
formed the nucleus of the American space ... and nuclear missile programs.

At Huntsville, Alabama, with von Braun and his crew
the Americans started experimenting with the very V2 rockets which had been launched on Britain.


V2 rocket tour at Nordhausen
Just after the German surrender ...
A US congressional delegation inspects the two, mile long underground tunnels
where V2 rockets were built by concentration camp inmates.

This was at Nordhausen in central Germany ... part of the Buchenwald 'family' of camps near Weimar.


V2 underground construction tunnel.
Late in World War 2
British and American bombing raids on Germany,

by night and by day respectively,
drove essential production (including V2's) underground
... and with Albert Speer directing these changes production actually went up!


Wernher von Braun

Wernher von Braun (shown in 1958) was the engineer and physicist who ran the German V (Vergeltungswaffe, Vengeance weapon) rocket program.
Although primarily an enthusiastic and talented rocket geek ... who later designed  US  ICBMs, and the great Saturn V moon rocket ...
he had also been an officer in the SS through all of World War 2 and had visited the Mittlebau-Dora V2 assembly facility ...
where the V2 rockets had been built by concentration camp slave labour - featuring summary executions, etc.



1960s
When you've got a new hammer ... every problem begins to look like a nail.

"Excavation for Water Conveyance with Nuclear Explosives"
[A paper from the proceedings of the third Plowshare Symposium, April 1964]

"They will beat their swords into ploughshares and their spears into pruning hooks.
Nation will not take up sword against nation, nor will they train for war anymore."



"The California Department of Water Resources is charged with a continuous study program for the future development of water resources throughout the State. The Atomic Energy Commission, through its Plowshare Program, is responsible for investigation and developing industrial uses for nuclear explosives. The West Side Conveyance System is a possible feature of future work for conveyance of water from the North Coastal area to areas of efficiency. Joint reconnaissance studies of this possible feature indicates substantial savings in cost may be possible if nuclear explosives can be used for excavation. Further studies are proposed for evaluation of hazards and engineering feasibility."


Operation Plowshare.
[The diagram above shows both conventional and nuclear elements of the possible project.
For reference: The bombs dropped on Japan yielded about 20KT or less]


"Conclusions:

1. It is technically and structurally feasible to construct water conveyance channels, in the Cretaceous formation of western Tehama County, by nuclear means.
2. Based upon current knowledge and a reasonable projection of knowledge expected to be developed prior to the contemplated time of possible construction (perhaps about 1985 or 1990), it would be possible to detonate the nuclear devices with safety.
3. Radioactive contamination of water flowing through the excavated channels, or in ground water, would be far less than the level of tolerance.
4. It may be possible to make significant savings in overall cost of the System. "




From a 1969 textbook ... here is how 'common' uranium eventually turns into lead.
Another problem with nuclear power generation.

U-238 to Pb decay chain.
Nuclear Waste Problem #2


... as you remember from the last page ...
the atoms of U-235 in a fission reaction get smashed up into a number of different radioactive elements.


Then ... each SINGLE unstable radioactive product of a fission reaction ...
has its OWN decay chain.


The particular 'uranium-238 to lead' decay chain above has a HALF-LIFE of about 4.5 billion years.

 This means ... after you have patiently waited 4.5 billion years ...

the other half of the radioactive atoms in your sample
will still be pinballing their way down the chain to lead.




Well at least North America is now safe
  and we are enjoying peace and post-war prosperity ...



Face the fallout.
'10 For Survival' (US 1959)
[Canada's booklet is better - see below - '11 Steps to Survival']



Fallout shelter.
... and must live there for at least a couple of weeks.

Don't forget drinking water and the bucket for 'you know what'.
'Fallout Protection' (US 1960)



Canadian nuclear activity fun book.
'11 Steps to Survival' (Canada 1971)


  By the early 1960s, with the much more destructive Hydrogen Bomb
available in quantity on both sides ...
(from 1 up to 25 megatons for 'strategic' - i.e. 'city' - bombs)

and with Soviet missile targetting accuracy greatly improved ...
urban civil defense efforts in preparation for an attack were futile ...


I'm with you, kid.
Making good hopeful citizens of Canadian kindergarten kids in 1954.
Before big H-bombs became just so darned popular.


Back in the early days of the 'Atomic Age' when Civil Defense was promoted, the influences of World War 2 were fresh in the minds of planners. Bomb shelters could provide good blast protection ... and a massive evacuation of a city on short notice would clog the roads, making military and emergency vehicle passage impossible. In addition, maintaining basic city services and 'wartime production' ... key in Britain during the prolonged 'Blitz' ... were only possible if people didn't 'take to the hills'.

Some circa 1950 US Civil Defense films describe the 'take to the hills fraternity' as being 'almost treasonous'. Afterwards, these people will always have to live with the fact that 'they let their family, their friends, their city ... down'. 'America's cities must fight!'

In fact, during World War 2, cities in which large firestorms had developed (Dresden, Hamburg, Tokyo) were very unhealthy places to be. Oxygen was consumed by the fires, causing suffocation of those citizens who were otherwise safe from injury in deep bomb shelters. The heat of huge fires also killed. For example, intense heat melted asphalt ... trapping people trying to flee down the streets like fly paper, or, like those terrible mouse glue traps ... to give a more modern reference.

During the early atom bomb days, you might survive using World War 2 techniques supplemented by the special knowledge developed from the experiences of those killed and injured at Hiroshima and Nagasaki. Primarily: duck under structural protection, protect the head and neck from debris, cover exposed skin to protect it from flash burns.

Once hydrogen bombs were developed ... those living in large cities, and receiving a 30 minute warning ... would have to depend on exceptionally good luck.



The Good Old Days of Atomic Bombs

Atomic cartoon.

In this cartoon of an atomic bomb ... you can see explosive charges forcing a mass of uranium 235 or plutonium together.
The charge becomes 'super-critical' (explosive) because 'split atom products' with tremendous energy ... in turn ...
split more and more atoms at an exponential rate.

However, the size (power) of an atomic bomb is limited because there is only so much atomic fuel you can bring together  ...
before it goes supercritical right there on your workbench, or within the bomb casing.

During the Manhattan Project work, the concept of a 'Super' was discussed.

It would use more powerful atomic fusion ... instead of fission ... as the main explosive process.

With an H-bomb:

A radioactive fission 'primary'
would be needed to set off the
'secondary' ...
a fusion reaction of 'heavy hydrogen' (deuterium or tritium).

A small fission charge would be plenty to produce the needed high energy neutrons ...
  but it unfortunately also made everything radioactive after the blast.

Happily, the designers could use all the hydrogen they wanted to make the explosion much larger.

There was no limit ... as there was with uranium/plutonium 'atomic weapons'.



World  War  II  atomic  bomb  -   about    20,000 tons   of TNT


'World War III' hydrogen bomb - up to  25,000,000 tons   of TNT



*  *  *

Here is an old and grainy simulation of a
1,000,000 tons of TNT (1 megaton) nuclear airburst over New York.

For scale, the black arrow points to the World Trade Center.
Poor old New York.

With greenhouse gas global warming, we have quickly forgotten about the good old days of 'Nuclear Winter'.
This unintended consequence of nuclear war was communicated to us rather late ...
about THIRTY YEARS after humans had the megatonnage to achieve it.

The idea was that maybe 100 nuclear detonations of the type shown above (1 megaton)
would throw enough smoke and opaque debris high into the atmosphere ... so that ...

The sun would probably disappear for a year or more,
the weather would get much cooler,
much of earth's natural flora and fauna would be affected,
and crops would fail.

Starvation, and elimination of any still-surviving human civilization would be the general result.
You could still have isolated 'Mad Max "civilizations" ' somewhere ...


But if you define 'civilization' as ...

books from Amazon delivered to your door  ...
Facebook  ...
arthroscopic knee surgery ...
Starbucks ...
prescription pharmaceuticals ...
  mutual funds and pensions ...
air travel ...

... and functioning systems to provide ...
petroleum products, hydro-electricity, clean piped water, sewers ...

After a large nuclear exchange ... followed by 'nuclear winter' ... civilization would be gone.



1980s

People generally think of bomber aircraft, or perhaps missiles delivering nuclear warheads to cities.

A more practical and elegant potential method of fighting and deterring nuclear war was once offered by submarines ... assuming it was always was ... and always will be 'impossible' to eliminate nukes. I can't remember the source, but at one point President Jimmy Carter almost became convinced that missiles and bombers could be eliminated if only submarines were retained.

After nuclear-propelled submarines became viable in the early 1960s, more sophisticated and compact ... warheads ... missile guidance systems .... and missile propellants ... resulted in the ability to conceal potent nuclear strike facilities at constantly changing locations under the oceans.

Consider a few of the benefits of using only submarines:

Boomer with ICBM hatches open.
Initially, intercontinental ballistic missiles - ICBMs - were the strategic (city destruction)
weapons carried by submarines.

Here you can see the missile hatches open on an old US sub.
An ICBM missile trajectory is powered on the way up to space ... and ballistic on the way down to the target.


Sea launch cruise missile.
Sea launch cruise missiles are smaller sub-sonic nuclear delivery vehicles
which can skim just above terrain to make radar detection more difficult.

*  *  *

But ... the Air Force lobbied to keep their bombers and Minutemen.
And this is how the picture developed as we approached the greatest danger of civilization-ending war in the 1980s.


The Nuclear JuggernautStrategic missiles and warheads. US USSR
from Moral Principles and Nuclear Weapons, Douglas P. Lackey, 1984


*  *  *

Minutemen launching.
How the world seemed likely to end in the 1980s ...  and how it may yet end in the future.
Minuteman missiles leaving their silos.


Old B-52 nose art slogan:

'We cater BBQs'

... now, in 30 minutes or less!



'Mandrake, the Redcoats are coming!'

2


But the missiles won't launch quite yet.


A time-honoured thought experiment is to consider whether these personnel are better described as ...
'armed battlefield warriors' - they do have side-arms ... or 'computer operators'.


Of course:
Throughout the nuclear weapons systems, you don't want people with delusions or dementia acting on their own  ...
so in addition to 'failsafe' systems and procedures like 'two separate keys' and 'time interlocks' ...
the armed forces had various personnel reliability programs to weed out danger.


Of course:
These PRP's don't apply all the way up the chain of command to the Commander-in-Chief.



"I can go into my office and pick up the telephone
and in twenty-five minutes seventy million people will be dead."

(Commander-in-Chief, November 1973)



"My fellow Americans,
I am pleased to tell you I just signed legislation which outlaws Russia forever.
The bombing begins in five minutes."

(Commander-in-Chief, 1984 microphone check)






Widespread development of 'the atom'

 brings security, peace, and prosperity.


Reductio ad absurdum


Remember?
We learned (above) that
back in the 1950s: "A-bombs may be carried in over a land border in a suitcase" ...

The knarled branches of the Canadian maples bade him farewell.


The border is even less effective at stopping the fallout from a Superpower Duel.
*Russia, USA, China ...

*One of these three countries has already used nuclear weapons in war ... twice.

The patterns consider the prevailing winds.
from Canada and the Nuclear Arms Race, 1983

The clouds of radiation coming from the west and south of Winnipeg are generally US ICBM complexes targetted by Soviet ICBMs.
Cold Lake and North Bay are two military targets within Canada.

Airbursts are preferred for conventional civilian and industrial targets ... which are easily destroyed by atmospheric over-pressure and fire.

As missiles are housed in reinforced concrete silos underground, groundburst detonation is indicated -
perhaps 1 megaton per missile silo would be used and the chart above shows the US having 1700 missiles in 1970.

There would be no way to quickly determine which missiles had already been fired by either side, so empty silos would be hit on both sides.

Sadly, groundbursts throw a lot of radioactive dirt and ash into the air ... creating the hazard of radioactive fallout downwind.


Because of their heavy reinforced concrete construction ... civilian nuclear power stations would be targetted for groundburst detonation.
  Both sides would argue these are legitimate industrial infrastructure targets.


Normal groundburst blast fallout
plus
the wide dispersion of nuclear reactor fuel from the destroyed reactor containment buildings ...
and
nuclear waste from spent fuel kicking around reactor sites in 'long term storage' containers with nowhere to go ...

would be spread widely over the urban areas surrounding the civilian reactors.


Hydrogen bomb test over water.

3.8 megatons





Given the antiquity of human civilization ...

Step Pyramid of Djoser, built 2630-2611 BCE


And the often desperate efforts, necessary to survive ...

Jean-Francois Millet, The Potato Harvest, 1858


And all the people, through all the years ...


1609 Galileo Galilei shows the heavenly spheres aren't perfect.



Who have worked to push back the darkness ...


Florence Nightingale back from the Crimea.



The Christians have the bomb, the Jews have the bomb, and now the Hindus and the Sikhs have the bomb. Why not the Muslims too have the bomb?
Prime Minister Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto 1972



Theodore Gericault, Nude Warrior with a Spear, 1810

Which single great power
has contributed so much to human civilization ...
that today it should have the right
to destroy all the efforts of the past, for all time ?


Which TWO great nation states should have the right to kill millions of people
and make the planet uninhabitable ...
because they have the right to protect their
'security' ... 'honour' ... or 'interests' ?

*  *  *

This is what happens when two old-fashioned nation states
don't believe in ceding power ... and seeking compromise ...
and don't solve their differences by arbitration instead of war.

Make the United Nations work!




Back to sitemap