Great War battlefield survivors - Part 1

'We support the troops!' ...'til the boys come home.




Newfoundland Quarterly
Many of the Newfoundland photographs and notices come from the 1915-1918 issues of this periodical.
While the images and captions are imperfectly preserved, they quickly take us back almost a century.



Kitties!
Cover: Europe's Greatest World War

The politicians who declare war ...
and the nationalists who promote the war as 'necessary and noble' ...
and those in business who benefit from it ...

are usually safely segregated ...
from those who must personally fight it.


The youth - and some of their elders - who joined the British Empire volunteer armies of the Great War were often
idealistic, patriotic - and, being young - considered themselves indestructible.

Socially, it was a normal expectation that the Empire's youth would want to 'do their part'.

The Great War was not foreseen ... much less planned ... as it eventually played out.

Some suggest that the profound theme of the Great War,
as considered through the literature written by its soldiers is ...
'innocence exposed to horror'.



Financing the War Emergency
The Glorious Dead
... and miscellaneous costs


In a war emergency it is essential for the leaders of society to ...
mobilize public opinion and support for sacrifice ... train the military ... and give them weapons.

No military plan survives contact with the enemy - as even the perfected German war machine discovered.
Innovative 'war-winning' tactics and weapons are quickly copied or countered by the other side.

Lives and money are too easily thrown away in the ensuing desperate effort by career military officers ...
who are under pressure to win.

The true long term costs are only considered in hindsight by historians.

No political leader has ever stated beforehand:
'We think it would be a good idea to fight a war for "The Survival of Humanity" ...
which will cost $1 billion when we are done'

  'Externalities' to the core wartime economy ... quite consistently in history ...
are the long term costs lived each day by the survivors.

The young soldiers do their part ... but find they were not indestructible after all.

After the war,
society's stoked-up patriotic fever for victory is replaced by relief ...
the moderately-involved citizens are 'war weary' and want to move on to more pleasant goals in their personal lives.
 
The solemn pledge to 'support the troops'
is neatly tucked away under the stone monuments to the Dead.




Brigus Newfoundland

A postcard shows Brigus - a 'railway-enabled' outport not far from St. John's.
Consider the state of advanced - or any - health care in this and neighbouring communities.




Some of the Newfoundlanders in the War


Lieutenant Robert Reid

Lieutenants and Second-Lieutenants were known as subalterns or 'subs' in the British Army.
(The British tradition pronounces 'Lef TEN ant' to avoid sounding French ...
for those officers 'lieu place tenant holding' for regimental colonels on the battlefield)

It was the subalterns who led platoons and companies of soldiers out of the trenches and into battle.
Providing superior leadership when a lot of men are dying, means you are likely to die too.

It has been suggested that the W.D. Reid of the Newfoundland Railway
lost interest in all of his projects after losing his eldest son.




Mary McGrath

Without figures for Newfoundland ... from a Canadian Government post-war publication ...
about 2400 Canadian nurses went overseas with the Canadian Expeditionary Force and served in
England, France, Belgium, Egypt, Greece and Russia.
Of these, 37 died : at sea (a Canadian hospital ship was sunk), or overseas of wounds or disease.




Nicholas P Evans





Battlefield survivors with limb amputations

To try to understand physical war wounds,
using an example which is at least easy to picture,
one could consider the 'limb amputations' as a group.


Canadian documents provide some idea of what might have been happening in the health care system
of Newfoundland and in the systems of 'the other cats' to meet the health care needs of war survivors.

Initially, there was no domestic manufacturer of artificial limbs in Canada.


In the April 1916 'Special Bulletin of the Military Hospitals Commission of Canada',
it was stated by the investigator looking at artificial limbs (limb prostheses):

"It must not be forgotten that the loss of a limb not only maims a man but, in most cases, reduces his total physical ability. The first step in this connection would be the transfer of the supply of the artificial limbs from the Militia Department to this Commission and the establishment of a central depot, either in Montreal or Toronto, where the best orthopedic advice is available and where vocational training could be given to the men while waiting for their limbs.

"In many workshops that I have visited, men only wore their limbs when going to and from the workshops. Many cases can be materially assisted by artificial appliances, but it is not advisable to make the men dependent upon these any more than is absolutely necessary. The supplying of complicated artificial limbs is not desirable."



St. John's General Hospital notice




St. John's General Hospital circa 1914

Thousands of Newfoundlanders joined the Newfoundland Regiment
to 'take a crack at the Hun' and support the Empire.
As this contemporary view of a major St. John's hospital shows ...
there will probably be a shortage of health care capacity when Great War survivors return.



German rehabilitation leg amputees

In an American textbook 'How Germany Cares for War Disabled - Lessons from the Enemy' (1918)
a photograph shows a systematic military approach to restoring the fitness of amputee soldiers.
Amputees with prostheses practice walking over obstructions while 'shouldering arms' under the supervision of an officer.
Another photo shows some soldiers hurdling with prostheses.
It is not clear how universal these efforts were.

Perhaps in Germany where major wars seemed rather ... frequent ...
it made sense for the state to have a more 'hands on' approach
  in managing the rehabilitation and productive occupation of war amputees.



German working arm prosthetic

Complicated, compared to Canadian prosthetic recommendations above,
the various adjustments for a German 'work arm' are shown.


German working arm prosthetic attachments

Germany had previous experience in caring for war amputees, with its population generally close to large urban centres.
Because of war losses, Germany had a relative shortage of male labour,
so there was a strategic advantage in maintaining the industrial productivity of its war amputees.

Canada did not have these characteristics.


German working arm
Filing metal parts

Photos of the German workers show them ...
planing, scraping, working at drafting plans, hammering,
nailing, and washing the other hand with a brush attachment ...


To repeat the Canadian recommendation of 1916  ...

"In many workshops that I have visited, men only wore their limbs when going to and from the workshops. Many cases can be materially assisted by artificial appliances, but it is not advisable to make the men dependent upon these any more than is absolutely necessary. The supplying of complicated artificial limbs is not desirable."






Phantom Limb Pain


In 1915, Wilfred Harris, physician to St. Mary's Hospital, London, and to The Hospital for Epilepsy and Paralysis ... was working as a captain in the Royal Army Medical Corps at the 3rd London General Hospital, which is mentioned later on this page in connection with Newfoundland and Canadian patients.

He put together a booklet entitled "Nerve Injuries and Shock" in the "Oxford War Primers" series.

"The hysterical cases are usually to be distinguished from true painful neuroma by the exaggerated condition of hyperaesthesia present, affecting large areas of skin, which should not be tender in neuroma. Any movement, moreover, is likely to cause apparent pain in the hysterical painful stump. Inconsistence of the patient with regard to his pain will usually give away his case. Thus I have seen a man, who had amputation performed through the middle of his forearm on account of an injury, develop intense pain in the stump a week afterwards, the flap being opened and explored by the surgeon after a fortnight. Nothing was found to account for this pain, and he was sent out of hospital, being told to wear his arm in a sling and protect it carefully. A fortnight later this man walked up from Maidenhead twenty-six miles to St. Mary's Hospital, with his arm swathed in cotton wool at least two inches thick, and carrying his arm in a sling on account of the intense tenderness any touch or movement provoked, as he said. Yet the very fact of his being able to walk with his arm in that condition proved beyond a possibility of a doubt that the tenderness was psychical and not physical. After unwrapping his limb nothing abnormal was found, though the man complained of intense hyperaesthesia for any touch or movement. However, firm treatment with faradism and the wire brush, combined with suggestive encouragement, dissipated the hyperaesthesia entirely and cured him of his trouble in less than five minutes."


The patient must have been well-motivated by something to walk 26 miles to a doctor's appointment.

I can't tell you if this is a case of phantom limb pain or not. Certainly this story suggests the difficulties which 'working class' British patients - educated 100 years ago without today's knowledge of the nervous system - would have if their symptoms were different from those anticipated by an 'expert' medical officer.

If an arm or leg was amputated in 1915 ... but the patient sometimes still felt the limb there - as if whole again ... and often felt great pain within the absent limb ... the patient might decide their sanity was being lost. In addition, chronic pain can often cause depression ... which, in turn, can make the pain worse. This would have been a treatment nightmare in 1915 for even an open-minded doctor with an abiding 'interest' in the patient's progress.

To be fair, in his book Captain Harris has only about 125 pages to cover the wide range of physical nerve injuries which can occur during war, so the fact that 'phantom limb pain' is not addressed at all in his book should not be too disappointing ... I guess.

The human nervous system is complex and wonderful and evolved over millions of years. It still has many secrets from medical science.

Young American military patients on TV documentaries of the 21st Century have stated that it feels as if their amputated arm is still present and burning in a fire, or is being actively crushed in a vice. No one knows precisely what explains phantom limb pain ... or how to treat it with complete success.

Intuitively, one would assume it must be triggered by the damaged nerves at the stump as Dr. Harris confidently states for the 'non-hysterical' cases of stump pain.

However, it seems more likely with today's knowledge ... that 'garbled signals' from the stump may interact somehow with the many nerve junctions at the spine, sending out an amplified cascade of 'bad pain signals' ... or maybe the secret of chronic phantom pain is somewhere in the 'mapping' of the whole body and its peripheral nerves inside the brain.

You can also imagine there are stress hormone 'signals' floating around in the body's chemical soup to make the symptoms worse.


Whatever causes intense phantom limb pain ... perhaps Dr. Harris overwhelmed the 'garbled signals' for a while with his electrical stimulation and the wire brush.


So to imagine a really depressing case ...
  a soldier volunteered to do his part,
  had a limb destroyed in battle,
then he got a poor-quality government issue prosthetic,
and he seems to be crazy, because he is 'imagining' phantom limb pain,
... and, in addition, the experience of chronic pain is making him depressed.

In lieu of adequate attentive medical care back in 1915,
 he can always drink alcohol, which will dull the pain for a while ...
whether the phantom pain originates at the stump, the spine, the brain - or all three for that matter!
But ... he'll need more and more alcohol to have the same effect ...
... and the alcohol itself will make the veteran's depression even worse over time ...





Youth of the Empire ! ...

 
My simplistic 'cartoon' ...
a 'patriotic message' for battlefield survivors ...

The innocence of youth is first exposed to the horror of the battlefield,
then to the horror of cost containment through bureaucracy.


Thank you so much for your recent idealistic and patriotic enlistment into the armed services of His Majesty.
First the good news : We shall be victorious ! ...  someday ... when we beat the Wiley Hun.

Awfully sorry about your friends and sibling(s) getting killed in the shellings and attacks ... bad show, that ... nonetheless, we Celebrate our Glorious War Dead!

Their problems are over and yours have just begun ... um, rather ... very sorry to hear about your life-changing injuries.

As you know, the War is full of surprises for all of us ... and we Leaders of The War haven't escaped scot-free either, you know : 

... We must now struggle to cope with the problems You Wounded are creating for Our War Effort. What a bloody inconvenience 'wastage' is!


Let us consider your Canadian House of Commons Special Committee on the Care and Treatment of Returned Soldiers, from July 1917 ...

"Your Committee has very thoroughly investigated the matter of the care and treatment at present being given to wounded soldiers, but has not, as yet, given an exhaustive study to the problem attendant upon demobilization and 'liquidation' of the war."

So 'cheer up', 'chin-chin', 'pack up your troubles' and all that ... after you are discharged and financially 'fixed' with a pension ... the war will soon be liquidated and we can all get back to normal life. Won't that be grand? ...


Returned to Canada by April 1917.
Disability as fixed by Medical Board at disembarkation port.

Number of
Soldiers
Up to 25 % disability
7,418
26 to 50 % disability
2,923
51 to 75 % disability
927
76 to 100% disability
1,975
583 cases - 'no record'


... and you will no doubt be proud to learn that the Americans have been studying and learning from our developing British system. Below is a flow chart they made of our processes in 1917 for their own military administration and politicians (we requested a copy because it looks so good on paper) ...

... sorry again about your life-changing injuries, the U-boat terror you may feel on the way back across the 'Pond', the military discipline and commotion of your 'rest' period, and all the medical officers, and 'boards', and bureaucracy, you are enduring in your state ... and the additional anxiety all this may cause you ...

Godspeed to your happy 'Final Disposition' in Canada at the bottom of the chart.

We know you have a choice of empires to fight, die, and devastate your future plans for ...
thank you for choosing The British Empire and we hope to see you again*.


* Once per annum maximum ... on Remembrance Day ...
You see ... if voters (and women) understand that war maims and cripples people ...
it will be hard to promote the important idea that EVERY future war is a 'necessary' war for 'freedom'.
Remember: Don't complain and make nuisance of yourself ... there's a good soldier ...

God Save the King !




Here is an American administrative textbook's flow chart of British processes, 1917 ...
there was no 'handout' for Empire (e.g. Canadian, Newfoundland) wounded to explain the process they were going through.

Great War wounded, flow chart


Below is the Britsh schedule for calculating ' % disability ' for disability pensions.
No similar document for Canadian Great War pensions has turned up.
Keep in mind regular 'service pensions' would also be paid.

British Great War schedule for 'degree of incapacity'



Treatment of wounded 'Dominion' troops in general ...
'Politics and the CAMC'



CAMC was the Canadian Army Medical Corps, including people such as physician and field surgeon John McCrae, the author of  'In Flanders Fields'.

RAMC
was the Royal Army Medical Corps - the senior medical service (British) for the Empire troops fighting in Europe and in the other theatres such as Greece, Turkey, Italy, Palestine, Mesopotamia, etc.


Consider a nursing career in Corfu!
Postcard of the port of Corfu - part of the Salonikan Theatre of war.
About 500,000 Allied troops fought in the area, including British and French units.
Our Serbian allies (... yes!) fled to this island after the Austro-Hungarian/German invasion of Serbia
and the overland death march of its population to escape.
(94,000 Serb soldiers killed; 174,000 captured or missing; civilian death toll unknown)



You know how 'the media' can be ... reporting scandalous stories which trouble governments ...

After the battle known as Second Ypres in April 1915, the Canadian government found it politically necessary to send a Colonel Bruce of Toronto to investigate the CAMC and formulate recommendations. In the time-honoured Canadian tradition of  'critics be quiet ... we are studying the issue'  the Government bought itself some time.

Whether Colonel Bruce was right ... with his report which made many powerful people look as if they were building their careers and supporting the war - but not the troops... or whether he was a prima donna surgeon ... might be open to debate by some. He presented his confidential report on September 20, 1916. Bruce and his fellow investigators believed that their observations should have been used to improve care ... but they also must have known that their report could be used as a political football if the confidential recommendations were made public ... and of course they were ...

In fact, his criticisms were framed by some as disparaging the sincere and sacrificing John McCraes of the war ... largely this was probably done to draw attention away from the failures of those in power. The politicians punished him and his supporters ... then quietly cherry-picked most of his recommendations. As his 1919 career summary below indicates, he didn't need the headache of Canadian 'government work' to earn a living or get recognition for his abilities ...

Colonel Herbert A. Bruce, MD, FRCS, was Associate Professor Clinical Surgery, University of Toronto; and Surgeon at the Toronto General Hospital. He was also Past President of the Toronto Academy of Medicine; Regent of the American College of Surgeons, Washington; Fellow of the American Surgical Association, Vice-President of the Congress of Clinical Surgeons of North America, and former President of the Ontario Medical Association.


Colonel Herbert Bruce



If you are going to review the care of a patient population - i.e. wounded Canadian soldiers - first you must have a look at them.


This is where Dr. Bruce had found them ...

Location of hospitalized Canadian troops
Numbers represent miles from Folkestone - the closest point to France.



Some details from the Bruce Report ...

Canadians were discovered to be in 800 different British hospitals!


Newfoundlanders at 3rd London General Hospital
According to the map above, Canadians were also patients at Wandsworth (not a VAD facility).
Originally a Victorian school for orphan daughters of British military personnel,
  Wandsworth was quickly converted to the '3rd London General Hospital' to handle Great War wounded.


Selected Bruce Report findings continue ...

End of details from the Bruce Report.


To summarize some of Dr. Bruce's points :

There are at least two possible reasons to explain the conditions to which Dr. Bruce took exception ...
  1. Very little about the Great War was foreseen and planned for. The need for health care, and particularly psychological care, initially were war fighting 'frills' ... unlike the priorities for 'victory' and/or protecting the stability of ante bellum power structures [wow, I wrote that!] So the Big Priorities which received the most leadership attention and resources were ... maintaining the Empire's status, and colonial possessions, and international alliances ; war 'strategy' and weapon production, and paying companies for producing the weapons; raising and training massive volunteer armies and supplying them with food clothing shelter transportation weapons and officer leadership. It is no wonder that health care of the soldiers was a mess ... it was just too low on the long list.

  2. The Empire's Leaders ran things and set the expectations for the Dominions. For example, considering the Newfoundlanders and particularly the Canadians ... Field Marshal Sir Douglas Haig's 500 page diary yields the following typical Imperial perspective. After the Commander-in-Chief of the British forces (Haig) was formally asked that Canadian units be allowed to fight together as a 'Canadian army' ... Douglas Haig wrote: "I could not help feeling that some people in Canada regard themselves rather as 'allies' than fellow citizens of the Empire!" ... Realistically then, what were the chances that Empire leaders would let Canadian medical personnel focus on treating the Canadian soldiers?



This notice in The Newfoundland Quarterly - at the end of the war -
first got me interested in reading about some of the experiences and 'health outcomes' for battlefield survivors.


St. John's asylum notice




The View of a Subaltern at the Front


Lieutenant Robert Reid

I don't have a picture of the soldier who wrote the following poem,
so here is Lieutenant Reid again to represent 'middle management'.


If you were a military mail censor,

  (usually an administrative officer or a chaplain)

with the responsibility of:

1. protecting military information
2. monitoring the general morale of the troops through their mail

How might you assess Lieutenant Murphy's health?




Out of the Line!
A typical soldier's lyric.
by Lieutenant Leo Murphy
British Expeditionary Force

There's a wondrous earthen shelter,
  Far beyond the setting sun,
Where a gallant crowd may anchor,
  When their fighting days are done.
Free from "strafing", shock and battle,
  Working parties safely o'er,
Where the Subs all slumber softly.
  And ... there's peace forevermore

They have left the slippery duckboards,
  They have left the blinking trench,
And in parting from these loved spots,
  It has meant an awful wrench.
Comes at last the place called ...
  Where the billets are the best,
And the dangers of the front line,
  Vanish in the days termed "REST"

France February 1917






Back to sitemap